Ratings and reviews
Petrella's Italian Cafe Photos
Hours
| Monday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Thursday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Friday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Saturday | 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Petrella's Italian Cafe Reviews
Petrella's is so amazing ! Wish the building was bigger because I think they have outgrown their space . But that just shows you how amazing they are because they are always Booming I always like to go here when I am looking to get a good spaghetti or lasagna and you can't go wrong with Lasagna Wednesday's . I also enjoy their house salad or Greek salad and their broccoli soup is DELICIOUS ! Oh and don't forget their appetizer: Fried Mushrooms are delicious We always receive good service from anyone in the establishment.
The lasagna was great, house salad was perfect, and my wife's shrimp and crab manicotti. Was too full to order dessert, but next time definitely. Service was amazing as well. I took my wife and special needs son. The waitress came over many times and never had to ask for service once. The surrounding inside was just right. Quiet, and peaceful.
Picked up dinner this past weekend for my husband and I. We ordered the combo plate with chicken Parmesan, Italian sausage and spaghetti with meat sauce along with the chicken fettuccini Alfredo. With our meals, we got a minestrone soup and salad with ranch dressing. All of the food was super hot and fresh, the flavor was great. I feel like the portions have gotten slightly smaller but maybe it was an off day.
Amazing food, quick & friendly staff . The best Italian food I've had in Pensacola. Large portions enough for two to share & be full. Worth every dollar spent, inside dining or to go options either way the food is great!
Great food. Great service. Great ambiance. Lunch portions shown also include a side salad with options for a small up charge. My only suggestion is to plan your trip (s) as they do not accept reservations and space is limited but service is prompt. 2 personal thumbs ups... you can also order their daily specials To-go if time is not on you side and...they serve Coke products. Winner! Winner! Italian dinner!
The food is always AMAZING, locally owned and PHENOMENAL , service from KELLY. KELLY went above and beyond for us, we had drinks half full or more the entire time. We had a bunch of questions she answered them all with kindness and patience. EVERYONE who works there gives good service and they are all kind people!! As always the food was AMAZING HOT AND FRESH!!! We will definitely be back we order To-Go A LOT, don't always have the pleasure of dining in but we will DEFINITELY dine in with KELLY a bit more often after today's experience!! It is a small restaurant, mom and pop feel to it, LOCALLY OWNED, if there is a wait for a table(always during busy times) it is ALWAYS worth the wait. THANK YOU very much KELLY for the amazing dinner experience!!
We've visited Petrella's a few times over the years. The only reason we haven't been regulars is how busy they often are in the evenings. With only about 8 booths and 6 tables, the wait time (at least for us) was maybe 15 minutes (not bad), but sometimes I see a lot of people outside waiting. When we left, the wait time was probably 25 minutes. The interior isn't really anything to write home about. Some aspects could use some updating and/or repair (seat upolstery, ceiling tiles, carpet). Servers are helpful. The food had both positives and negatives. The salad was basic and the garlic bread was lackluster. But the entrees were large and tasty. Prices were so-so, but given the amount of food, it was likely just right. Overall, I enjoyed what I was there for: the food and would return.
Always pleased! Never leave hungry. And seem to have leftovers every time. Recommend the pizza and Italian hoagie .staff and Servers are really friendly . One of our favorite spots to eat.
My husband and I went to Petrella's for their all you can eat Spaghetti & Meatballs Monday Night Special for only $8.99 per person. It includes a delicious salad, the yummiest buttery garlic bread, and spaghetti with meat sauce and super tasty meatballs! The salad was terrific... and the dressings seemed homemade and fresh... I had the blue cheese (awesome), and my husband had the thousand island (awesome too)... lots of veggies and the best croutons... truly a meal in itself!!! The all you can eat is truly all you can eat... but the portions are so generous, i challenge you to get seconds... although we did get seconds on the meatballs (yep... they allow that)!!! Our server Ally was like the energizer bunny! She was taking excellent care of so many tables masterfully! She was so friendly and made everyone feel like they were her only guests! We live close by, and have been here multiple times... and each time it's really great! It's no wonder this place almost always has a full house and has been a staple around here for decades! Give this place a try sometime (you won't regret it), and support local small business! Promise I'll get more pics next time!
Petrella's Italian Cafe
Petrella's Italian Cafe in Pensacola, Florida, is more than just a dining spot; it's a destination for those who crave authentic Italian flavors. Nestled at 2174 W 9 Mile Rd, this charming eatery combines a welcoming atmosphere with a menu bursting with classic Italian dishes and modern interpretations. Whether you're a local or a visitor, Petrella's promises a culinary journey that leaves a lasting impression.
Discover the Heart of Italian Cuisine at Petrella's Italian Cafe
When you step into Petrella's, you're greeted with the comforting aroma of fresh pasta, simmering sauces, and baked bread. The ambiance blends rustic Italian charm with the friendly vibes of a neighborhood cafe, making it perfect for a family dinner, date night, or casual lunch.
The menu at Petrella's is a testament to the richness of Italian gastronomy. From traditional favorites like Spaghetti Carbonara and Chicken Alfredo to creative dishes like their house-special Seafood Lasagna, every plate is crafted with precision and love. The inclusion of freshly sourced ingredients elevates each dish, ensuring that every bite bursts with flavor.
Why Locals Love Petrella's Italian Cafe
Petrella's has become a beloved spot in the Pensacola community, and for good reason. Its dedication to serving high-quality food with a personal touch sets it apart. Guests often rave about the warm service, where staff make an effort to remember regular patrons and personalize their dining experiences.
The restaurant's focus on variety ensures there's something for everyone. Whether you prefer hearty pasta dishes, flavorful seafood options, or lighter fare like salads and soups, you'll find it here. Their carefully curated wine list further enhances the meal, offering perfect pairings for their signature dishes.
A Menu That Celebrates Authenticity
Italian cuisine is all about simplicity done right, and Petrella's embodies this philosophy. Their menu showcases a range of dishes that highlight fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes. Start with an appetizer like the creamy Shrimp Scampi Bruschetta or a classic Caprese Salad. For the main course, options like Veal Parmigiana, Eggplant Rollatini, and wood-fired pizzas are sure to delight.
Petrella's also caters to special dietary needs with gluten-free and vegetarian options, ensuring no one misses out on the Italian experience. And don't forget to save room for dessert! Their house-made Tiramisu and Cannoli are the perfect sweet endings to a satisfying meal.
Petrella's Location and Atmosphere
Located at a convenient spot on W 9 Mile Rd, Petrella's Italian Cafe is easily accessible, making it a go-to spot for locals and tourists alike. The cozy yet spacious interior features inviting decor inspired by the Italian countryside, with warm lighting and charming accents.
Petrella's also offers outdoor seating, allowing guests to enjoy their meals al fresco on breezy Florida evenings. For those who prefer dining at home, their takeout options ensure you can savor their dishes wherever you are.
What Guests Are Saying About Petrella's Italian Cafe
Reviews for Petrella's speak volumes about its popularity. Patrons often highlight the generous portions, reasonable prices, and consistently delicious food. One diner described it as "a little slice of Italy in Pensacola," while another praised the "friendly service and authentic flavors that keep us coming back."
The restaurant's welcoming vibe also makes it an excellent choice for celebrating special occasions. Whether it's a birthday dinner or an anniversary celebration, the staff goes above and beyond to make it memorable.
Experience the Best of Italian Dining in Pensacola
Whether you're exploring the menu for the first time or returning to savor your favorite dish, Petrella's Italian Cafe ensures an unforgettable experience. With its authentic recipes, welcoming atmosphere, and exceptional service, it captures the essence of Italian dining and brings it to the heart of Pensacola.
Visit Petrella's at 2174 W 9 Mile Rd, and discover why it's cherished by so many. From the first bite to the last sip of wine, every moment at Petrella's is a celebration of great food and warm hospitality.
Petrella's was great, I have not personally ate inside but I've ordered out 3 times so far and have not had an issue. The employees are very kind, food was great and the portions are huge! I would recommend the spaghetti and meatballs if you do decide to give the restaurant a try.